He Thought No One Wanted His $25M Business. He Was Wrong.
About a year ago, a business owner came to us and said he attempted to sell his business and the process failed. He had hired a business broker who effectively took a stack of tax returns, stapled them together, affixed a one-page summary, sent it out to a few buyers, and put it online.
After languishing on the market for many months, the business broker finally went to the owner, Ted, and said, “Hey, Ted, we’ve tried to sell the business. We’re not getting bites. You need to focus on improving the business and taking it back out to market at some point in the future.”
So, after a conversation with his attorney, his accountant, and his wealth manager, his wealth manager said, “Hmm, I wonder if this is being handled the right way.” I mean, after all, the business owner was making a lot of money. The wealth manager knew that because he was managing a massive stack of cash.
So, the wealth manager introduced him to me and I got a call from the wealth manager who said, “Paul, I’m a little bit concerned about how the process may have been run. Can you talk to my client Ted? So I had a chat with Ted. I took a look at the business. The fundamentals were strong. We ran a formal process and months later Ted was ecstatic when we closed that transaction.
Now, think about what Ted had been told prior to coming to us. Months and months of the business being on the market, zero traction, and his mandate now was to improve the business. That’s a pretty consequential conclusion to draw from a process that never reached the right buyers to begin with. Which brings me to today’s question. If I take my business out to market and it doesn’t sell, will buyers hold that against me later?
Hi, I’m Paul Giannomore. I’m an investment banker and I negotiate for a living. I think this is a really important question. It’s probably the most common question business owners ask. Everyone that goes to market asks me, “If I take my business to market and it doesn’t sell, will I be penalized in the future?” Business owners even ask themselves that question. And I think it’s an important one to consider because there are real costs associated with selling a business.
As a business owner, you go out to a sale process. It’s not like, hey, you toss it out there, see what happens, no distractions, you move on with your life. No, you’re focused on doing a lot of work for people like me and for buyers. You’re taking your eye off the ball. It could potentially distract your team. And then, of course, you have the potential cost from a breach of confidentiality.
You take your business out and you worry about your competitor down the street finding out, “Oh, Ted’s selling his business. Let me steal his employees”, “Oh, Ted’s selling his business. Let me tell all the customers, don’t do business with Ted anymore because he’s selling his business and you don’t know if he’ll be there in 6 months. We’re a safe bet.”
So, a lot of things can go wrong in the sale process. But I think there’s a silent almost subconscious question baked into that as well. And I think that question is if I take my business out to market and it doesn’t sell, what does that say about me? Right? Because many of us our identities are attached to these businesses.
We’ve spent 10, 20, 30, 40 years building them. We take it out to market and nobody wants it. What does that say about our life’s work? And so I think there’s some real practical things that you should think about as you start to approach the potential of selling your business.
When Ted first came to us, we sat down and he said, “You know, my business spent months on the market. I really don’t know if we got any bites or not. I spent almost 30 years building this business. And quite frankly, I was surprised. The broker told me up front, this should sell. Here’s what I should get. I was super excited. None of that happened.”
So when somebody says “went out to market,” my first question is what does that actually mean? Which buyer saw it? Why were they selected? What sort of information did they get? What sort of process rules were established? What sort of materials were prepared? Right? Like you know, I can send out, I could take a fire protection business to market and send out information to a thousand potential buyers, but if none of them have any interest in fire protection, it’s not going to do me any good.
So my first question is understanding how the process was structured. What buyers are contacted, and what sort of information did they receive? Were they engaged? Did they have any substantive discussions about the opportunity?
My other question is where did the deal actually die in process? Was it at the front end where no one had any interest at all in the business whatsoever?
That might be a buyer problem, a selection problem with regard to the acquisition universe. Did the deal die in diligence? Did it get all the way through due diligence, terms were agreed on, and the buyer found something wrong with the business or something they perceived as negative and pulled out?
Did the buyer and seller not see eye to eye on price? I mean, if there was no buyer in the world that was going to pay more than $25 million for a business and the seller wanted 100 million for it, that business is not going to sell. But does that mean it was a failed sale process? No. There was a disparity between what the seller was willing to accept and what the buyers were willing to pay.
So, when a seller comes to me after having been through a failed sale process, the first question I go to is, “Was it really a sale process?” And I’m going to give you a present-day real life example of this. About 2 months ago, I was in the US and I was speaking at a conference. When I was done, I was walking out.
I was approached by a man in his late 70s who shook my hand and introduced himself and said, “Hey, Paul, my name is Robert. I came here to this conference when I found out you were speaking here. I live locally and I really wanted to ask you a question.
I said, “Sure, Robert, no problem.” We walked off to the back where there was a bar, leaned up against it, and I said, “What’s going on?” He said, “I just tried to sell my company, took my business out to market, and no one wanted it after spending my entire adult life building this business.” So, I said, “Okay, let’s talk about that.” And he reached into his bag, he pulled out a folder, he opened it up, and he said, “This is my company.”
He’s like, “I’ve owned and operated it for over 50 years. I thought I had a great company and I’ve just been turned down. Can you take a look at this?” And of course, my first question is always, “What does go to market mean?” So, I asked him that. And I took a look, you know, I took a look at his business and when you opened up the folder, I think my immediate unprofessional response was like, “I could sell the shit out of that business.”
I mean, he had a great, great $25 million in revenue, 25% EBITDA margins, growing at a rapid clip. I mean, I was thinking to myself, this is a fantastic business. What happened?
And he said, “You know, I’ve been at this for over 50 years. I educate myself, always. I watched your videos online. I’ve read a lot. I decided I was going to take the business out to market. I put together this little package here,” and he had a wonderful package. I was actually surprised. I was like, “This is great. I like what you’ve done with the financials. It’s pretty clear to understand exactly what I’m looking at. ”
And he said, “You know, I decided to approach two acquirers, the biggest two acquirers in my industry who had been on me for years. Both of them had said, “Hey, if you’re ever going to sell, we want to buy you.” Great. So, he said, “I happen to know the presidents of both of the firms. So, I called them up. I had some lunch meetings and some dinner meetings, and we traded some information back and forth.
And then within a week of each other, both declined to move forward with the deal. So here I am like my life’s work and no one wants to buy it. And so we got to talking and we exchanged contact information. I said, “Robert, after this conference, maybe you and I can have a chat.”
So the following week, we had a discussion. I just said, “Listen, Robert, I can think of a variety of different ideas for you right now, but let’s start with the basics. I’m going to do my best to help you here.
Do you mind introducing me to the presidents of these acquirers that you know you can do an email intro and just say, “Hey, this is Paul. If you wouldn’t mind please chat with him about your thoughts on this transaction.” Sure enough, both of them responded very quickly and they’re happy to chat with me.
So, the first president and I got on the phone and I said, “Hey, Robert’s exploring using us as an adviser and he said he attempted to sell his business to you and I just wanted to get a little bit more information.” President number one said, “Robert’s a great guy and I’ve known that business personally for 26 years. I really, really wanted to buy the business.
But when I sat down with Robert, he was extremely explicit upfront that, you know, his wife had passed away, his kids are grown and out. He was very focused and engaged in that business, and he didn’t want to retire. He wanted to phase out over the next five or six years.”
And he said, quite frankly, that was a problem for me. I really like Robert as a person. He’s somewhat of a disaster for the business because he himself is curtailing growth. He really needs to be in control of the business. I talked to him a lot about what I would do with management and all I heard from him is no, no, no, no.
So he said, “We just gracefully bowed out.” And I said, “Did you explain this to him?” He’s like, “I didn’t have the heart. I didn’t want to hurt his feelings.” So, I just told him we have other strategic initiatives and it wasn’t going to make sense for us to do this at this time. Fine.
Next president. When I talked to the next president, I heard some very similar things. Robert did of course say he wants to stick around for 5 years. And this president actually was very happy with that. He said, “I’m going to give Robert some projects. I’m going to get him away from management of the business. There’s other things he could work on. Totally fine with that.
I love the business. It’s number one on my acquisition list of deals to do. I put together my internal proposal. CFO got involved. We went to our investment committee and they said, “No way. We’re a publicly traded company. We’ve been experiencing decelerating customer demand. I’ve got a lot of capital allocation issues right now. It’s too complicated to focus on this transaction.”
And he was like, I told Robert, I really like your business right now. The investment committee said no. Maybe at some point in the future. So what I heard and what Robert heard were very different things. You know, what I heard from these guys is I took my business out to two buyers and I didn’t complete a sale. What Robert actually said to me was nobody wants to buy my business after almost 50 years of building it.
As you can see, there’s a very big difference between going out and finding all the potential appropriate acquirers for a business and running a process versus calling up two competitors, having them not be interested in it for one particular reason at one particular point in time, and then conclude, “No one wants this business.”
So, I went and fired up the old Zoom and got on with Robert. I said, “Robert, you are in a much much better position than I thought you were in. This is great news. You’ve got two buyers that actually really love your business and built a great business. One is having its own set of internal complications, no fault of your own. The other one had some structure issues that they wanted to talk about from a management continuity perspective going forward.
And as I was talking, I saw on the other side of the screen, Robert was just like shaking his head saying, “I thought this was going to be more successful. I thought I really built something special.” And he was ruminating about the fact that he didn’t make progress with these two buyers, the only two buyers that he actually contacted. And then it struck me and it struck me that I see this all the time.
You know, when I deal with stuff like this, I think about the concept of psychological shame that exists in every one of us, including you to one degree or another. And it’s the concept of if we take guilt versus shame, right? Guilt says I did something wrong. Shame says I am bad. And business owners in a failed process need to be very disciplined about separating the business from themselves.
And what I mean by that is business transactions can fail for a variety of reasons. Like I already mentioned, the process is a big one. You didn’t talk to the right buyers. You didn’t give them the right materials. You didn’t run a proper process. That’s huge. That takes place in a lion share of these things.
Another aspect of that is there’s something in the business that needs to be improved. For example, your business might have a lot of customer concentration. Maybe your largest customer is 30% of your revenue and that gives acquirers concern.
Well, that’s something that can be worked on over time. Maybe it’s clarity on financial information. Maybe acquirers just couldn’t get comfortable with the financials for one reason or another. Well, that’s something that can be worked on.
If you can isolate the issues within the business, that’ll help you steer the course into the future because now you know exactly what to do, right? So, I wasn’t able to sell my business because I didn’t run a proper process and contact the right buyers. That’s one issue. There’s a particular issue in my business that while unfortunate, I can fix and at some point in the future go back out into the market.
And then there’s of course the area that’s harder to recover from and that’s if you lie. For example, let’s say that you provide acquirers false data knowingly and willingly. If you are a seller, that’s really difficult to get along with. You know, one of the reasons that transactions die is because sellers go into a process and they want to sell for $50 million, for example. And let’s say during bidding, now all of a sudden, it’s 60 million.
Well, sometimes instead of feeling like, man, that’s great. I want to close this tomorrow. I don’t want to lose that additional $10 million. Sometimes they say, “Hm, maybe I underestimated what this business might be worth. Let’s shoot for 70.” And so now the goalpost continues to move throughout the process.
Fatigue sets in on the buy side, right? Like a buyer just doesn’t want to go through perpetual negotiations. Or let’s say you negotiate one thing and then you negotiate another thing and they think they’re done with the deal and then you’re negotiating something else.Sometimes, deals die because buyers just don’t want to deal with you, right? And that’s reasonable and that happens.
Those are slightly more difficult to recover from than the failed process because you didn’t go to the right buyers or the failed process because you had too much customer concentration and that’s something you have to work on fixing. Buyers remember, you know, sometimes people at acquirers change, but there’s written records and NDA files and, you know, you attempt to go out to a business in 2023 and now it’s 2026.
For the most part, buyers will remember you having gone to the market and that’s why when you reenter the market, you are very specific about what the event that occurred before that may no longer be the issue. So, for example, yes, I went to market before and I only contacted two buyers. Now, I’ve hired an adviser. I’m going to do this right.
Yes, I went to the market three years ago and throughout the process, I realized my customer concentration was too high or I had an overdependence on a particular management team or whatever the issue was that made the acquirers uncomfortable. Remember, in a sellside process, it’s your job as a seller to elicit as much information as you possibly can from the buy side.
So, if you’re going to go out to market, you better make it a really good learning process and understand what it is that the buyers want. You know, I told Robert, I said, “Robert, you went in and told those guys what you wanted, and I think that’s great. Did you spend the time understanding what they wanted?” Right? Did you spend the time understanding how they would utilize you or if they felt like it would be better if you weren’t involved anymore? Is that a question that you asked? No, it wasn’t.
But back to my point, if you go back out to market and this is why it failed, here’s how I’ve corrected the issue. Here’s evidence to support that.Buyers typically do not care. In fact, many of them may be very excited to see you. So, I think you know my overall perspective is if you do go to market and this is what I tell my clients, if we go to market and we run the process appropriately and fairly and we treat the buyers with dignity and respect.
If we take ownership for where we mess up, who knows what’s going to happen, right? I don’t know what neither I nor the seller himself actually knows what sort of skeletons might come out of the closet. And I never cease to be amazed by what pops up.
But if that does happen, for us to be open, honest, take responsibility. We’re due. Even if the process fails, we will be a joy to work with. We will be men and women acting in integrity. And if we own an asset that buyers want, they will absolutely come back to the table. So, those are some of the best ways that you could safeguard your ability to go back out in the market, all else being equal.
Now, price tends to be an issue, right? I have another client who for many years has told me that the buyer universe, the amalgamation of all potential buyers for his business, does not truly understand the value of his business. You know, and my point is, well, I don’t, I don’t know. Do you understand the value of your business? Considering, you know, we’ve been out to market, there’s a massive disparity between what the seller wants and what the buy side’s willing to pay. And that’s okay.
You know, you’re going out into the market to voluntarily sell their business, right? It is your decision. You’re making the decision. Do I take the cash in hand in exchange for an asset that I own or do I prefer to continue to own the asset, right? And if you’re able and willing to continue to own the asset, you can do that. So that’s a luxury that’s afforded to you out in the market.
And it’s something that you have to think about in a process because there will come a time when you go to market that that’s a decision we’ll ultimately have to make. Is the best price and terms that I’m being offered right now, is that something I’m willing to accept to hand over this asset, my business? And that’s always your decision.
And I think it’s a very legitimate way to tie down the process. You know, sometimes guys get concerned and say, “Well, I want $60 million for my business, but what if they only offer me 40?” So, they only offer you 40. What’s your decision? “Well, my decision to hold on to the business.” Fine. All you have to do is tell the buy side, this misses the mark for me, let’s have this discussion at some point in the future.
And by the way, now that you’ve spent a couple of months with me, now that you’ve looked through this business, do you have any suggestions that you might give me to make this business more valuable to an acquirer like you? And I got to be honest with you, nine times out of 10, they’ll say yes. If I were you, I would focus on X, Y, and Z. So, in closing, I wanted to say going out to market is not costless, right? It takes time, money, and effort for me.
It also exposes you to risks that I think more times than not are overblown. It’s really quite rare for me to see confidentiality blowups, but there are some risks and costs associated with doing it. Going out to market now and having a failed process or not otherwise selling your business for a variety of reasons does not foreclose your ability to do it in the future.
The big areas are dishonesty or just otherwise being a dick quite frankly. But if you can avoid those sorts of things and you can learn from the process, your risk exposure to not getting attention from those buyers in the future is extremely low.
If you went through a process that went nowhere and would like another perspective, please track me down in the contact in the description below for a conversation. As well, if you have any questions or suggestions for future episodes, please leave a comment in the comment section below.
Again, I’m Paul Giannomore. Thank you for watching.
Your Business Didn’t Sell. Will Buyers Hold It Against You?
It’s one of the most common questions business owners ask before going to market: if I try to sell my business and it doesn’t sell, will buyers penalize me later? In this episode, Paul Giannamore, investment banker and Managing Director of The Potomac Company, shares two real stories of failed sale processes and explains why a deal that didn’t close rarely ruins your chances of selling in the future.
The Real Cost of Taking a Business to Market
Selling a business isn’t a no-risk experiment. A sale process takes the owner’s time and attention, can distract the team, and carries the risk of a confidentiality breach, such as competitors poaching employees or telling customers the business may not be around in six months. Paul also points to a quieter fear many owners carry: if no one buys my business, what does that say about my life’s work?
Ted’s Story: A Broker Process That Never Reached the Right Buyers
Ted hired a business broker who stapled together his tax returns, added a one-page summary, sent it to a few buyers and listed it online. After months with no traction, the broker told Ted to go improve the business. His wealth manager suspected the process was the problem. Potomac reviewed the business, found strong fundamentals, ran a formal sale process, and closed the transaction. The business was never the issue. The process was.
Robert’s Story: A $25 Million Business “Nobody Wanted”
Robert, who had built his company over five decades, approached the two largest acquirers in his industry on his own. Both declined, and he concluded no one wanted his business. But the business had $25 million in revenue, 25% EBITDA margins and strong growth. When Paul spoke with both buyers, the real reasons became clear:
- One buyer loved the business but was concerned about Robert’s plan to stay involved and keep control for another five or six years.
- The other made the business its top acquisition target, but its investment committee said no because of internal capital allocation issues.
Neither decision was a verdict on the quality of Robert’s business. Calling two competitors is not the same as running a sale process.
Why Business Sales Fail and Which Problems You Can Fix
Paul encourages owners to separate the business from themselves. As he puts it, guilt says “I did something wrong,” while shame says “I am bad.” Most failed sales come down to fixable issues:
- Process problems: the wrong buyers were contacted, materials were weak, or no real process was run.
- Business issues: customer concentration (for example, one customer making up 30% of revenue) or financials buyers couldn’t get comfortable with.
- Price gaps: the seller’s expectations and the buyers’ offers were too far apart.
The harder failures to recover involve seller behavior: knowingly giving buyers false data, or moving the goalposts on price and terms until buyers walk away from deal fatigue.
Going Back to Market After a Failed Sale
Buyers will often remember that you went to market before. That is why, when you return, you should be specific about what caused the earlier process to fail and show evidence that you’ve fixed it, whether that means hiring an adviser, reducing customer concentration, or strengthening management. Paul notes that in most cases buyers don’t hold it against you, and many are glad to see the business come back.
When the Price Isn’t Right
Selling is always a voluntary decision. If the best offer misses your number, you can decline and keep owning the asset. Paul recommends asking the buyers who walked through your business what would make it more valuable to them. In his experience, nine times out of ten they will tell you.
Key Takeaway
A failed or stalled sale process does not close the door on selling your business later. Run a proper process, treat buyers with honesty and respect, learn what they want, and fix what you can. Do that, and the risk of buyers ignoring you in the future is extremely low.
If you’ve been through a sale process that went nowhere and want another perspective, contact The Potomac Company for a conversation.
Frequently Asked Questions
If my business doesn’t sell, will buyers hold it against me later?
Usually not. Buyers may remember that you went to market before, but a failed or stalled sale rarely closes the door. If you return with a clear explanation of what went wrong and evidence that you fixed it, many buyers are glad to see the business come back.
Why do business sale processes fail?
Most failed sales come down to three causes: a poor process (the wrong buyers, weak materials, or no real competitive process), a fixable business issue such as customer concentration or unclear financials, or a gap between the price the seller wants and what buyers are willing to pay.
Does contacting one or two buyers count as taking my business to market?
No. Calling a couple of competitors is not the same as running a sale process. A proper process identifies all the appropriate acquirers, gives them the right information, and sets clear process rules. Two buyers declining at one point in time does not mean no one wants your business.
What are the risks of putting my business up for sale?
Selling takes time, money, and attention away from running the business, and it can distract your team. There is also the risk of a confidentiality breach, such as competitors poaching employees or warning customers. These risks are real, but in practice confidentiality blowups are rare.
What makes it harder to sell a business after a failed attempt?
The hardest failures to recover involve the seller’s conduct: knowingly giving buyers false information, or repeatedly moving the goalposts on price and terms until buyers walk away. Process problems and business issues like customer concentration are much easier to fix before going back to market.
How should I go back to the market after a failed sale?
Be specific about why the earlier process failed and show how you corrected it. For example, explain that you now have an adviser running a full process, or that you have reduced customer concentration or strengthened your management team. Buyers typically do not care about a past attempt once the issue is resolved.
What should I do if buyers offer less than I want for my business?
Selling is always your decision. If the best offer misses your number, you can decline and keep owning the business. Before you walk away, ask the buyers what would make the business more valuable to them. In most cases, they will tell you exactly what to focus on.
How can I protect my ability to sell my business in the future?
Run a proper process, treat buyers with honesty and respect, and take ownership if problems surface. Use the process to learn what buyers want. If you do that and own a business buyers want, they will come back to the table, even if the first process does not end in a sale.